The Homeowner’s Dilemma
It’s a hot Kansas summer day. Your air conditioner breaks down, and now you’re faced with the big question: Do I repair it or replace it?
As a homeowner, this decision can feel overwhelming. At Jack Harrison Heating & Air Conditioning, we guide families in Olathe, Overland Park, and Johnson County through this choice every season. The answer depends on several factors — age, cost, efficiency, and comfort. Let’s walk through the signs so you can make the best decision for your home.
1. Consider the Age of Your System
Most central AC units last 12–15 years in Kansas, depending on maintenance.
If your system is under 10 years old, AC repairs often make sense.
If it’s 12 years or older, AC replacement may save money long-term.
💡 Pro Tip: If your AC uses R-22 refrigerant (phased out in 2020), replacement is often more cost-effective than continuing repairs.
2. Look at Repair Costs vs Replacement Value
A helpful rule of thumb is the $5,000 rule:
Multiply the age of your AC by the cost of the repair.
If the total is over $5,000, replacement is usually the smarter option.
Example: A 12-year-old unit needing a $600 repair = $7,200 → likely time to replace.
3. Check Your Energy Bills
Older AC systems lose efficiency, meaning higher monthly energy bills.
If your bills are steadily climbing despite regular maintenance, your AC may be costing you more than a new system would.
Modern high-efficiency AC units (with higher SEER2 ratings) can cut cooling costs by up to 20–40%.
4. Evaluate Comfort Levels
Does your home feel unevenly cooled? Is humidity higher than it should be? Are some rooms cooler than others? These comfort issues often mean your system is struggling.
Repair may work if it’s a small issue like a capacitor or thermostat.
Replacement is better if your AC can’t keep up with demand anymore.
Zoning might be an option. Schedule to have on of our Jack Harrison HVAC technicians come out and give you options to consider!
5. Frequency of Breakdowns
One repair every few years is normal. But if you’re calling us every summer for a new part or emergency service, it’s a sign your AC is nearing the end of its life.
6. Safety & Reliability
If your AC shows signs of refrigerant leaks, electrical issues, or overheating, it’s not just about comfort — it’s about safety. In these cases, replacement may be the most responsible choice.
Benefits of Replacement
While a new AC is an investment, the benefits include:
Lower Utility Bills thanks to energy-efficient technology.
Quieter Operation with modern, variable-speed systems.
Better Indoor Air Quality and humidity control.
Warranty Protection for peace of mind.
Potential utility and tax rebates for savings - usually time sensitive
Why Johnson County Homeowners Trust Jack Harrison
When you’re stuck between an AC repair and an AC replacement, you need an honest answer. That’s where our team stands out:
Family-Owned & Operated: We treat your home like our own.
Honest Pricing: We prioritize repairs first, replacement only when it truly makes sense.
Free Estimates & Second Opinions: No pressure, just expert advice.
Fast Response Times: Because a hot house can’t wait.